Summary

What is internal carbon pricing? It is a price per tonne of CO2 equivalent that a company sets for itself and uses in investment decisions, budgets or charges to business units. The three main models are a shadow price (used in appraisals only), an internal fee (actually charged) and an implicit price (derived from what you already spend on reductions). ESRS E1 asks companies in CSRD scope to disclose internal carbon pricing schemes, and IFRS S2 asks for the price used in decisions. First action: pick one model and test it on your next three capital projects.

Illustration of a price tag on a carbon cloud inside a coin representing internal carbon pricing

Two projects reach the investment committee. One saves energy and emits less. The other is cheaper today and emits more. On paper, the cheaper one wins. Add a carbon price to both, and the ranking can flip.

That flip is the whole idea of internal carbon pricing. This guide shows the models, how to choose a price, and how to disclose it in Germany, the UK, the US and Canada.

What Are the Three Models?

ModelHow it worksBest for
Shadow priceA notional price added to project appraisals; no money movesCapital planning and strategy
Internal feeBusiness units pay a charge per tonne into a central fundChanging behaviour and funding reductions
Implicit priceThe cost per tonne you already pay through programmes and standardsUnderstanding current effort

How Do You Choose a Price Level?

Anchor the price to something defensible. Many companies start from the EU ETS allowance price for European operations, or from the cost of the most expensive reduction they already accept. Then set a rising path, because investments last for years. Review it annually and write down the logic, since reporting auditors will ask. Our carbon reporting requirements guide explains the data side.

What Do the Four Markets Expect?

MarketExternal carbon priceDisclosure link
Germany (EU)EU ETS, plus the national fuel emissions trading systemESRS E1 asks about internal carbon pricing; CSRD applies above 1,000 employees and EUR 450M turnover
UKUK ETSVoluntary UK Sustainability Reporting Standards, based on IFRS S2
USNo federal price; California cap-and-trade and regional schemesCalifornia SB 253: Scope 1 and 2 report due November 10, 2026
CanadaIndustrial output-based pricing; the consumer fuel charge ended April 1, 2025Securities climate project paused

How Do You Put It to Work?

  1. Pick the model: Start with a shadow price if finance is sceptical
  2. Set scope: Decide whether it covers Scope 1 and 2 only or includes Scope 3
  3. Test on live decisions: Re-run three recent investments with the price
  4. Govern it: Name an owner and approval route
  5. Disclose it: State the model, price, scope and how it affects decisions

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a shadow carbon price?

A notional price added to project appraisals to reflect future carbon costs. No cash is charged.

Is internal carbon pricing mandatory?

No, but ESRS E1 and IFRS S2 ask companies to disclose it if they use one.

What price should we use?

One you can defend. Many firms start near the relevant market price and raise it over time.

Does it replace compliance carbon costs?

No. EU ETS allowances and other statutory costs still apply. Read our EU ETS guide for those.

Leave a Reply