In February 2024, the NGO Transport & Environment (T&E) published an analysis of 565 voyages by 20 ships from Maersk, MSC, CMA CGM, and Hapag-Lloyd. It estimated that the carriers charged more in EU ETS surcharges than the scheme cost them on roughly nine in ten voyages, and cited an extreme case of about EUR 325,000 for Maersk. Maersk disputed the analysis, saying it lacked many cost factors. The EU ETS covered 40% of maritime emissions in 2024, 70% in 2025, and 100% from 2026. This case shows the full ESG compliance picture for logistics companies: direct carbon costs, FuelEU Maritime, customer Scope 3 data requests, CSRD and SECR reporting, and supply chain due diligence.

On January 1, 2024, maritime shipping entered the EU Emissions Trading System. Ships of 5,000 gross tonnage or more calling at EU ports became liable for carbon costs on every voyage. The industry knew it was coming. Maersk, MSC, CMA CGM, and Hapag-Lloyd all introduced emissions surcharges to pass on the costs to customers.

What the industry didn’t expect was the scrutiny that followed. In February 2024, T&E published an analysis of 565 voyages by 20 ships operated by Europe’s four largest container carriers. T&E estimated the actual EU ETS cost per voyage from ship emissions, route distance, and the prevailing EU allowance price. It then compared that estimate to the emissions surcharge each carrier billed customers.

Infographic on the EU ETS surcharge dispute and essential ESG compliance information for logistics companies in 2026, including EU emissions trading system details, compliance framework, customer requirements, and a seven-step compliance process.
An infographic on the EU ETS surcharge dispute and ESG compliance requirements for logistics companies in 2026.
Advertisements

T&E concluded that the carriers charged more than the estimated ETS cost in about nine in ten of the voyages. Press reports quote figures from 86% to nearly 90%. T&E’s estimates put the average profit per voyage highest for Maersk, and in one extreme case it estimated that Maersk charged about EUR 325,000 more than the ETS cost on a single route. Maersk rejected the findings. It said the analysis was flawed, that it used inaccurate and selective data, and that it did not use the EUR 90 per tonne carbon price T&E assumed. T&E said it contacted all four carriers about their surcharge methodologies, and only Hapag-Lloyd responded.

Readers should treat the per-voyage figures as T&E estimates and the carriers’ position as disputed. Either way, the episode makes one point clear for logistics companies in 2026: the EU ETS creates carbon costs and commercial scrutiny, and customers want transparent surcharge methods along with verified emissions data.

How the EU ETS Actually Works for Maritime Logistics

The EU ETS for maritime shipping launched with a phased implementation. In 2024, shipping companies had to surrender allowances for 40% of their verified emissions. That rose to 70% in 2025 and reaches 100% from January 1, 2026. For voyages between two EU ports, 100% of emissions are in scope. For voyages between an EU port and a non-EU port, 50% of emissions from that leg are in scope. Ships calling at EU ports must also surrender allowances for 100% of emissions while at berth.

Shipping companies must purchase one European Union Allowance (EUA) for each tonne of CO2 emitted, and EUA prices move with the market. From 2026, the system also covers methane and nitrous oxide. That raises the burden for ships that use fuels with higher methane slip.

Advertisements

Carriers publish emissions surcharges and update them quarterly, usually calculated on a trade-route basis. The surcharge amounts are visible to customers. The calculation methodology is not, which is the transparency problem T&E highlighted.

What Customers Actually Require From You in 2026

The EU ETS surcharge controversy matters beyond any one carrier’s pricing strategy. Your customers need your verified tonne-kilometre emissions figures, not surcharges. Under the EU CSRD, in-scope companies must disclose Scope 3 emissions, including upstream (Category 4) and downstream (Category 9) transportation and distribution. Your emissions are your customer’s Scope 3. This is what procurement and sustainability teams at CSRD-covered companies now request from logistics providers:

Logistics providers that cannot produce this data are losing contracts as major shippers in automotive, retail, and FMCG now require ESG data in freight agreements. Failure to deliver verified emissions data can trigger termination clauses. A customer paying a per-container emissions surcharge still needs the CO2 per tonne-kilometre figure for its own Scope 3 calculation, because the surcharge offers no insight into actual emissions.

For more on supply chain ESG requirements from the buyer’s perspective, see our post on ESG compliance for supply chains in 2026.

Advertisements

The Full ESG Compliance Framework for Logistics in 2026

The EU ETS is just one piece. Logistics companies operating in 2026 face a comprehensive ESG framework covering carbon costs, reporting obligations, and supply chain due diligence.

EU ETS for Maritime and Aviation

Maritime coverage is 100% from January 2026, and ships must surrender allowances for CO2, methane, and nitrous oxide. Persistent failure to surrender allowances can lead to expulsion orders and other enforcement at EU ports. Aviation has been part of the EU ETS since 2012, and the mandatory phase of the international CORSIA scheme begins in 2027. Air freight operators need to include both schemes in their plans now.

FuelEU Maritime Requirements

FuelEU Maritime entered force on January 1, 2025. Ships of 5,000+ gross tonnage using EU ports must cut the well-to-wake greenhouse gas intensity of fuel by 2% versus a 2020 baseline in 2025. This reduction progressively increases to 80% by 2050. Non-compliance triggers financial penalties, set at EUR 2,400 per tonne of very low sulphur fuel oil energy equivalent for the shortfall. Carriers often present this alongside EU ETS surcharges, so customers may see both.

Advertisements

CSRD and SECR Reporting Obligations

Since Omnibus I entered into force on March 18, 2026, the CSRD applies only to EU companies with more than 1,000 employees and more than EUR 450 million in net turnover. Those companies publish ESRS-aligned sustainability reports covering GHG emissions, energy, water, waste, biodiversity, and social metrics, with second-wave reports due in 2028 on FY 2027 data. Member States must transpose the changes by March 19, 2027, and CSRD penalties are set by each Member State. In the UK, logistics operators that are large companies or LLPs must report energy consumption and Scope 1 and 2 emissions in their annual directors’ reports under SECR.

California SB 253 for US Market Operators

US-organized logistics companies with $1 billion or more in annual revenue that do business in California must disclose Scope 1 and 2 emissions, with first reports due November 10, 2026. Scope 3 disclosure follows from 2027. CARB enforcement carries penalties up to $500,000 per year for non-compliance.

Supply Chain Due Diligence Under CSDDD, LkSG, and S-211

Germany’s LkSG applies now to logistics businesses with 1,000 or more employees operating in Germany. The annual BAFA report was abolished, but risk analysis, preventive measures, and complaints procedures remain. The EU Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive now applies only to companies with more than 5,000 employees and EUR 1.5 billion turnover, from July 26, 2029, with fines capped at 3% of net worldwide turnover. In Canada, logistics entities that import or produce goods and meet two of C$20 million in assets, C$40 million in revenue, or 250 employees must file an S-211 report by May 31 each year.

Advertisements

What Happens If Your Logistics Business Fails ESG Compliance

To fully understand ESG and environmental non-compliance penalties, check all sectors. See our guide to ESG non-compliance penalties in 2026.

How Logistics Companies Can Actually Comply in 2026

The surcharge dispute reveals a critical truth. Carbon regulations create costs. They also create commercial opportunities for businesses that understand the compliance landscape and can provide what customers actually need.

ESG Compliance Checklist for Logistics Companies (2026)

In February 2024, T&E alleged that major carriers were earning more from EU ETS surcharges than the scheme cost them, and Maersk disputed the analysis. Whatever the final truth, logistics companies in 2026 face two levels of ESG compliance: regulatory obligations and the need to provide verified emissions data to customers for their Scope 3 reporting. Companies that prioritize credible emissions measurement and transparent surcharge methods will gain a competitive edge, while those that cannot explain their charges risk losing contracts to more compliant providers.


Frequently Asked Questions

What ESG requirements apply specifically to logistics and transport companies?

Logistics companies face several direct obligations. These include the EU ETS for maritime and aviation operations (100% coverage for shipping from 2026). They also include FuelEU Maritime GHG intensity targets and CSRD sustainability reporting for the largest operators. Additionally, there are UK SECR energy and carbon reporting and California SB 253 for high-revenue US-market operators. Indirect obligations come from customers who need logistics emissions data for their own Scope 3 CSRD and SB 253 reporting. Commercial pressure from major shippers requires verified emissions data, SBTi alignment, and fleet decarbonization roadmaps as contract conditions.

Advertisements

What is the GLEC Framework, and why do logistics companies need it?

The GLEC Framework (Global Logistics Emissions Council) is the industry standard methodology for calculating and reporting greenhouse gas emissions from freight transport across all modes. It provides modal emission factors and calculation guidance for road, rail, sea, air, and inland waterway freight. Major shippers expect logistics providers to calculate and report emissions using GLEC Framework v3 (2023). Without GLEC-aligned reporting, your emissions data will not be compatible with customers’ CSRD Scope 3 calculations.

How does the EU ETS affect freight shipping companies?

The EU ETS extended to maritime shipping from January 2024. Ships of 5,000 gross tonnes or more on EU routes must monitor, report, and surrender EU allowances for 40% of emissions in 2024, 70% in 2025, and 100% from 2026. Coverage includes 100% of intra-EU voyage emissions and 50% of extra-EU voyage emissions. Financial exposure depends on fleet size and route network. Carriers pass costs through via emissions surcharges. A February 2024 T&E analysis estimated that surcharges exceeded actual ETS costs on most voyages, and the carriers disputed it, so shippers increasingly ask for transparent methods.

Do small logistics and courier businesses need to comply with ESG standards?

Small logistics and courier businesses below direct CSRD and SECR reporting thresholds still face ESG compliance pressure through two routes. First, if they supply large companies within CSRD scope, those customers require verified emissions data for their Scope 3 Category 4 and 9 calculations. Inability to provide this data risks losing the contract. Second, greenwashing rules apply to all logistics businesses regardless of size. Any sustainability claim about fleet, operations, or carbon footprint must be substantiated. The EU EmpCo Directive, the UK CMA, the Canadian Competition Act, and the FTC Green Guides apply regardless of company size.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply